USDA Loans vs. FHA Loans: Which Costs Less?
WHAT YOU'LL LEARN
How USDA and FHA loans compare on down payment, fees, and eligibility
What each loan could cost on a $350,000 home
When USDA makes more sense—and when FHA is the better fit
WHAT YOU'LL LEARN
How USDA and FHA loans compare on down payment, fees, and eligibility
What each loan could cost on a $350,000 home
When USDA makes more sense—and when FHA is the better fit

A USDA loan usually costs less than an FHA loan, since you can buy with no money down and the fees run lower. The trade-off is that USDA comes with two requirements FHA doesn’t have: the home has to be in an eligible area, which usually means a small town or a suburb outside a big city, and your household income has to fall under a set limit.
If either of those rules you out, FHA becomes the better choice. It works anywhere, has no income cap, and is easier to get when your credit score is on the lower side, so it picks up right where USDA leaves off.
Below, we’ll walk through how the two loans differ, what each would cost on a $350,000 home, and which one makes more sense for your situation.
Are USDA and FHA Loans the Same Thing?
They’re easy to mix up, since both are government-backed and both are designed for buyers without a large down payment saved. They come from different departments of the federal government, though, and they follow different rules.
FHA loans carry insurance from the Federal Housing Administration, an agency within HUD. USDA loans are guaranteed by the U.S. Department of Agriculture through its Rural Development office, a program created to encourage homeownership outside the country’s largest cities. In both cases, a private lender like Atlantic Bay makes the loan, and the agency stands behind it. That backing is what helps government-insured loans offer terms that would be hard to find otherwise.
So, they’re two separate programs, and you’ll pick one of them for your purchase rather than blending the two.
USDA vs. FHA Side by Side
Here’s where the two programs line up and where they part ways.
USDA loan | FHA loan | |
|---|---|---|
Down payment | None | 3.5% with a score of 580 or higher |
Where you can buy | USDA-eligible areas only | Anywhere in the U.S. |
Income limit | Yes, up to 115% of area median, counting the whole household | None |
Upfront fee | 1% guarantee fee, can be financed | 1.75% premium, can be financed |
Annual fee | 0.35% | 0.55% at the standard down payment |
How long the annual fee lasts | Life of the loan | Life of the loan below 10% down |
Credit | No program minimum; automated approval commonly at 640 | 580 program minimum for 3.5% down |
Property types | Single-family primary residence | One to four units, owner-occupied |
Closing costs | Can be rolled in when the home appraises above the price | Seller credits of up to 6% can cover them |
As of August 2026, per USDA Rural Development and HUD guidelines. Fees, limits, and eligibility areas are updated periodically.
Who Qualifies for Each Program
USDA: the address and the household
USDA eligibility starts with the property. The home must sit in an area USDA considers rural, and far more of the map qualifies than the word suggests, including plenty of small towns and suburbs on the outer edge of metro areas. The quickest way to find out is to enter the address on the USDA eligibility map before you get attached to a listing.
Income is the second gate, and it has a wrinkle that catches people. USDA looks at the income of everyone who lives in the home, including adults who won’t be on the loan. A grown child with a full-time job or a relative who moves in with you can push the household over the line, though deductions for dependents, childcare, and certain other expenses bring the counted figure back down. The limit itself varies by county and household size.
The property also generally has to become your primary residence, and you usually can’t already own a place nearby that meets your needs.
On credit, USDA files usually run through the agency’s automated system, which commonly approves scores of 640 and above. Below that, a lender may still be able to approve the loan through manual underwriting, which means more documentation and closer review.
FHA: credit and debt
With FHA, you can buy a home anywhere, and there’s no cap on what your household earns. The focus instead is on your credit score and how much you already owe each month. A score of 580 or higher lets you put 3.5% down, and scores between 500 and 579 can still work if you bring 10%. FHA is also generally more flexible about your debt-to-income ratio as long as the rest of your application looks strong.
What Each Loan Costs on a $350,000 Home
Here’s the same house financed both ways on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.5%. The USDA version requires nothing down. Its 1% guarantee fee adds $3,500, which most buyers fold into the loan, bringing the balance to $353,500. Principal and interest lands near $2,234, and the 0.35% annual fee adds roughly $103, for a monthly total around $2,337.
The FHA version starts with a $12,250 down payment. Its 1.75% upfront premium adds about $5,911 to the loan, for a balance of $343,661. Principal and interest runs about $2,172, and the 0.55% annual premium adds roughly $158, putting the monthly total near $2,330.
Example figures for comparison. Based on a 6.5% rate over 30 years and program fee rates as of August 2026, with property taxes, hazard insurance, and closing costs left out.
Monthly, it’s a coin flip. The two payments land within about $7 of each other. Where USDA pulls ahead is the $12,250 you get to keep, plus roughly $2,400 less in upfront fees. Having that cash still in the bank matters more during the first year of ownership than most people expect, when the water heater or the air conditioner picks its moment.
One thing the two share: at these down payments, both annual fees stay for as long as you keep the loan. Understanding how mortgage insurance works helps explain why. Closing costs are handled a little differently, too. USDA can let you roll closing costs into the loan when the home appraises above the purchase price, while FHA buyers usually lean on seller contributions to cover them.
Where FHA Comes Out Ahead
USDA’s advantages only apply if you can use it. FHA is the better route when:
The home is outside a USDA-eligible area. Most in-town neighborhoods in larger cities fall here.
Your household earns more than the local limit. Keep in mind that USDA counts everyone living in the home, which is easy to overlook.
Your credit score sits below the USDA automated threshold. FHA’s lower floor of 580 opens the door sooner, and there are practical ways to buy while your credit is still recovering.
You want a duplex or small multifamily you’ll live in. FHA covers owner-occupied properties with up to four units. USDA is limited to single-family homes.
Can You Switch From FHA to USDA Later?
This is one of the most searched questions on the topic, and the answer is usually no. USDA’s refinance options are limited to loans USDA already guarantees or made directly, so an existing FHA loan generally can’t be moved into the program.
For homeowners who want to shed FHA mortgage insurance, the usual path is refinancing into a Conventional loan once there’s enough equity. A conventional loan at 80% loan-to-value or lower carries no mortgage insurance at all.
That makes the decision at purchase more important. If you qualify for USDA today, price it out now rather than counting on a move later.
Work Through Both Options With a Mortgage Banker
A few of the deciding details are hard to pin down on your own. A Mortgage Banker can confirm whether the address qualifies, add up your household income the way USDA counts it, and run your file through USDA’s automated system. From there, you’ll see a USDA quote and an FHA quote next to each other, built on your own numbers rather than an example. A pre-approval pulls all of that together into a price range you can shop with.
Frequently Asked Questions
Chances are, if you're wondering about it, someone else has too. Here are answers to some of the questions we hear most often.
For buyers who meet both USDA requirements, generally yes, since it removes the down payment and carries lower program fees. When the home sits outside an eligible area, your household income runs above the local limit, or your credit needs more flexibility, FHA is usually the stronger fit.
Both can be assumed by a buyer who qualifies. That buyer has to meet the program’s credit standards, and for a USDA loan the household income limit generally applies as well. An assumption takes lender approval and more time than a standard purchase, so build that into the calendar whether you’re buying a home with one of these loans or selling it.
You’d choose one program or the other for the first mortgage on a home, because each carries its own approval, appraisal, and fee structure. Pairing either loan with down payment assistance is a separate question, and whether that works depends on the specific assistance program.
Both charge an upfront fee and an annual fee. USDA calls its version a guarantee fee, at 1% up front and 0.35% a year. FHA calls its version a mortgage insurance premium, at 1.75% up front and 0.55% a year at the standard down payment. As of August 2026, per USDA and HUD guidelines, both annual charges typically stay in place until the loan is paid off or refinanced when little money goes down.
On FHA, a score of 580 is the program floor for putting 3.5% down, while borrowers between 500 and 579 need 10% down. USDA publishes no single minimum, but its automated underwriting system commonly approves files at 640 and above, and lenders may consider lower scores through manual underwriting. Expect some lenders to layer their own stricter requirements on top of either program.